16 Scarboro Street

About this property

Step into a piece of Malton Village history at 16 Scarboro Street, a designated heritage home filled with character, charm and exceptional potential. Known historically as the Tomlinson/Johnston House, this distinctive property blends the warmth and craftsmanship of its original design with a substantial 1984 addition, creating a home that offers far more space and flexibility than its charming exterior might suggest.From the beautiful century brick and decorative gingerbread detailing to the impressive nine-foot ceilings in the original principal rooms, this is a home with personality. The spacious kitchen features quartz countertops, a large island and work surface, porcelain flooring, stainless steel appliances including a wall oven and cooktop, and a bright bow window overlooking the rear garden. Walk out directly to the deck and enjoy an easy connection to the backyard.The main level also features a full bathroom with a whirlpool tub, while the home's flexible layout offers a variety of options for extended or multi-generational living.Upstairs, a separate entrance, additional kitchen and two bathrooms, including one 2-piece bathroom, provide excellent potential for an in-law suite or private family living space.The lower level adds even more versatility, featuring a walkout recreation room, kitchen and direct access to the yard. With its separate lower-level feel and existing amenities, this space could be reimagined as a studio-style living area, in-law space, guest retreat, home office or entertainment zone.With generous living space, multiple kitchens, separate access points and a walkout lower level, this is a truly unique home ready for its next chapter. A little updating will allow you to add your own personal touch while preserving the character and charm that make this property so special.A rare opportunity to own a piece of Malton's history while creating a home that works beautifully for today's lifestyle.

Property details

MLS® Number

W13778772

Property Type

Detached

Style

2-Storey

Lot Size

54.36 × 112.66 feet

Garage

Detached

Basement

Finished with Walk-Out

Heating

Forced Air

Cooling

Central Air

Annual Taxes

$6,162

Listed

September 14, 2026

Brokerage

RE/MAX HALLMARK YORK GROUP REALTY LTD.